Something just clicked in my mind when reading these theories. We all know that the writers and producers have brushed off the theory that the show will follow the book in terms of Ali having a twin…however…I think they are just postponing this by all these false leads. My theory is that Alison’s twin pushed Toby’s mom out the window at Radley….and I think that Mrs. DiLaurentis is covering up the twin thing. They have made too many links to the twin aspect (the poster, the scary Halloween story). I think they are just leading us on a wild goose chase….but I am keeping my fingers crossed that the show ends up surprising me in terms of who A is.
Thank you, Missy, for this post submission.
We want this, too! Definitely seems like they will go “the twin route” eventually. Too many details will be left unaccounted for if the writers/producers don’t include some sort of twin aspect having to do with either Ali or Cece, or both of them. And we, too, hope the show ends up surprising us (we loooong for this). Thinking back to S2, Mona as A was not so shocking. Recently dark!Ezra really got to us in terms of surprise, though insidiously. For the ultimate reveal, they’ll definitely have to step up the surprise factor. Here’s to hoping it’ll involve so much more than the existence of twins.